forestsofpine: (Default)
forestsofpine ([personal profile] forestsofpine) wrote2023-09-29 07:32 pm

General Fandom Stats: Characters Tagged With Alpha/Beta/Omega on AO3

An Army friend of mine sent me this tweet this morning knowing that I like fandom stats. It's a reaction to this TikTok video. I thought it was hilarious that all seven members of BTS are among the characters most often tagged as omega on AO3, and was immediately curious to see what the corresponding alpha list looked like. (Spoiler: all seven members of BTS are ALSO among the characters most often tagged as alpha on AO3. 😂)

Toastystats has done some omegaverse stats in the past, but none very recently, so I decided to see what the current picture looks like. I decided to re-do the same omega tag search as the TikTok OP to make sure I had the latest data, and to check the alpha and beta character tags as well. However, I'm not a statistician or anything, so there's no fancy graphs.

Here's what I found:



Methodology

I used AO3's tag search, and searched canonical Freeform tags for the terms "alpha", "omega", and "beta", then skimmed the list manually and picked out every alpha or omega character tag with more than 500 works tagged, and every beta character tag with more than 100 works tagged. I excluded a few tags such as "Alpha John" that didn't specify which John.

Because I did it manually and was skimming fairly quickly, it's possibly I might have missed a few - if you notice any omissions, let me know in comments!

It has also been my experience that the number of works listed in the tag search results isn't always the same as the number when you visit the actual tag page. I didn't compare the number of works listed on the tag pages, so it's possible that some characters might have been over- or under-counted as a result of this quirk.

A quick note re: Teen Wolf and possibly other werewolf canons: The Alpha Derek and Alpha Stiles tags seem to be synned to Pack Alpha Derek and Pack Alpha Stiles in AO3's system, which makes it basically impossible to tell which are omegaverse fics based on the Alpha Character tags alone, vs which are just standard canon werewolf pack dynamics. However, there are Omegaverse Omega Derek and Omegaverse Omega Stiles tags, which for some strange reason showed up as having 6 and 68 works respectively on the tag search results. I thought this was weird enough to click through on. Sure enough, the actual number when I looked at the tag page was 290 for Derek and 1688 for Stiles. The other Teen Wolf characters with Omegaverse Omega tags also had some suspiciously low numbers in the tag search results. I didn't include Teen Wolf data in the table below since I'm not sure what's going on there.

Data

Characters marked with a single asterick (*) are on two lists. Characters marked with double astericks (**) are on all three.

Data was collected September 29, 2023.

Characters tagged with alpha/beta/omega on AO3
RankAlpha CharactersNumber of WorksOmega CharactersNumber of WorksBeta CharactersNumber of Works
1Alpha Jeon Jungkook**7476Omega Park Jimin (BTS)**5498Beta Jung Hoseok | J-Hope**1156
2Alpha Bakugou Katsuki*4481Omega Midoriya Izuku**4782Beta Kim Seokjin | Jin**804
3Alpha Kim Namjoon | RM**4113Omega Kim Taehyung | V**3621Beta Kim Taehyung | V**759
4Alpha Min Yoongi | Suga**3906Omega Jeon Jungkook**3213Beta Min Yoongi | Suga**482
5Alpha Steve Rogers*3110Omega Tony Stark*2924Beta Park Jimin (BTS)**453
6Alpha Kim Taehyung | V**2803Omega Min Yoongi | Suga**2791Beta Kim Namjoon | RM**355
7Alpha Jung Hoseok | J-Hope**2258Omega Kim Seokjin | Jin**2688Beta Jeon Jungkook**332
8Alpha Bucky Barnes**2148Omega Bakugou Katsuki*2678Beta Sero Hanta192
9Alpha Park Jimin (BTS)**1999Omega Jason Todd*2002Beta Kim Seungmin (Stray Kids)190
10Alpha Kirishima Eijirou*1738Omega Dean Winchester*1774Beta Midoriya Izuku**168
11Alpha Kim Seokjin | Jin**1637Omega Will Graham1585Beta Uraraka Ochako162
12Alpha Midoriya Izuku**1598Omega Bucky Barnes**1574Beta Kirishima Eijirou*155
13Alpha Dean Winchester*1584Omega Steve Rogers*1454Beta Alfred Pennyworth150
14Alpha Hannibal Lecter*1437Omega Kim Namjoon | RM**1286Beta Kaminari Denki*139
15Alpha Todoroki Shouto**1321Omega Louis Tomlinson*1251Beta Tim Drake*132
16Alpha Castiel (Supernatural)*1291Omega Wèi YÄ«ng | Wèi Wúxiàn1217Beta Bucky Barnes**131
17Alpha Harry Styles*1241Omega Harry Potter*1194Beta Bruce Banner129
18Alpha Tony Stark*1233Omega Katsuki Yuuri1160Beta Clint Barton129
19Alpha Lán Zhàn | Lán WàngjÄ«1144Omega Peter Parker1120Beta Hwang Hyunjin128
20Alpha Victor Nikiforov1077Omega Dick Grayson*1017Beta Todoroki Shouto**118
21Alpha Bruce Wayne*1043Omega Jung Hoseok | J-Hope**1015Beta Hunk (Voltron)117
22Alpha Dick Grayson*957Omega Todoroki Shouto**998Beta Han Jisung | Han116
23Alpha Sam Winchester*952Omega Steve Harrington903Beta Ashido Mina115
24Alpha Jason Todd*899Omega Keith (Voltron)890Beta Niall Horan108
25Alpha Robin Buckley788Omega Tim Drake*882Beta Yang Jeongin | I.N107
26Alpha Louis Tomlinson*775Omega Eren Yeager841Beta Sam Wilson106
27Alpha Bang Chan (Stray Kids)718Omega Kaminari Denki*791
28Alpha Shinsou Hitoshi641Omega Harry Styles*776
29Alpha Gojo Satoru628Omega Lee Felix (Stray Kids)754
30Alpha Harry Potter* ‎599Omega Obi-Wan Kenobi753
31Alpha Kuroo Tetsurou557Omega Lance (Voltron)703
32Alpha Iwaizumi Hajime551Omega Aizawa Shouta | Eraserhead678
33Alpha Seo Changbin525Omega Bruce Wayne*624
34Alpha Lee Minho | Lee Know523Omega Draco Malfoy624
35Alpha Aemond "One-Eye" Targaryen520Omega Nancy Wheeler609
36Alpha Ben Solo519Omega Jaskier | Dandelion578
37 Omega Castiel (Supernatural)*573
38 Omega Itadori Yuuji568
39 Omega Hinata Shouyou556
40 Omega Lucerys Velaryon (Son of Rhaenyra)549
41 Omega Oikawa Tooru540
42 Omega Rey (Star Wars)519
43 Omega Sam Winchester*506
44 Omega Hannibal Lecter*502




L to R: Jungkook, Jimin, and J-Hope of BTS, the #1 alpha, #1 omega, and #1 beta on AO3, respectively


I thought it was fun to see which characters have fandoms with firm ideas about their omegaverse designations and which ones can't make up their minds.

Multitalented guys that they are, it turned out that all seven members of BTS were not only in the top 21 characters tagged as omegas, but also in the top 11 characters tagged as alphas, plus they made up all seven of the top seven characters tagged as betas.

Okay, I lied. ONE fancy graph:



It's safe to say their prominance in the results is partly just due to the sheer size of the BTS fandom: more than 210,000 works total, and more than 15,000 works tagged as omegaverse on AO3, more than any other fandom.

However, BTS also has a rather high percentage of omegaverse fics relative to the total number of fics in the fandom. About 7.0% of the total number of BTS fics are omegaverse, compared to 3.9% for Boku no Hero Academia (2nd highest total number of omegaverse fics), 2.7% for Supernatural (3rd), and 1.8% for the Marvel Cinematic Universe (4th). I was curious if a high percentage of omegaverse works might be a trend in RPF, but One Direction and Stray Kids, which both also had multiple members in the table above, were at 4.2% and 4.5% omegaverse, respectively. Even Supernatural RPF, where omegaverse originated, was lower than BTS at 5.2%.

I didn't check the percentage for every canon represented in these lists, but I did find at least one with a higher percentage of omegaverse fics than BTS. I was impressed that Aemond and Lucerys from HBO's House of the Dragon made it onto the lists already despite being from a fairly new canon, and found that the HoTD fandom is currently almost 8.4% omegaverse works on AO3.

Besides the tannies, other characters who appeared on all three lists included:

  • Bucky Barnes (Marvel)
  • Midoriya Izuku (BNHA)
  • Todoroki Shouto (BNHA)


Characters who appeared on both alpha and omega lists included:

  • Bakugou Katsuki (BNHA)
  • Bruce Wayne (DC)
  • Castiel (Supernatural)
  • Dean Winchester (Supernatural)
  • Dick Grayson (DC)
  • Hannibal Lecter (Hannibal)
  • Harry Potter (Harry Potter)
  • Harry Styles (One Direction)
  • Jason Todd (DC)
  • Louis Tomlinson (One Direction)
  • Sam Winchester (Supernatural)
  • Steve Rogers (Marvel)
  • Tony Stark (Marvel)


Kirishima Eijirou (BHNA) was the only character to appear on both alpha and beta lists, and Kaminari Denki (BHNA) and Tim Drake (DC) were the only characters to appear on both omega and beta lists.

Characters who appeared only on the alpha list included:

  • Aemond "One-Eye" Targaryen (House of the Dragon)
  • Bang Chan (Stray Kids)
  • Ben Solo (Star Wars)
  • Gojo Satoru (Jujutsu Kaisen)
  • Iwaizumi Hajime (Haikyuu!!)
  • Kuroo Tetsurou (Haikyuu!!)
  • Lán Zhàn | Lán WàngjÄ« (MDZS) - top ranked character to appear only on the alpha list
  • Lee Minho | Lee Know (Stray Kids)
  • Robin Buckley (Stranger Things)
  • Seo Changbin (Stray Kids)
  • Shinsou Hitoshi (BNHA)
  • Victor Nikiforov (Yuri on Ice)


Characters who appeared only on the omega list included:

  • Aizawa Shouta | Eraserhead (BNHA)
  • Eren Yeager (Attack on Titan)
  • Draco Malfoy (Harry Potter)
  • Hinata Shouyou (Haikyuu!!)
  • Itadori Yuuji (Jujutsu Kaisen)
  • Jaskier | Dandelion (The Witcher)
  • Katsuki Yuuri (Yuri on Ice)
  • Keith (Voltron)
  • Lance (Voltron)
  • Lee Felix (Stray Kids)
  • Lucerys Velaryon (House of the Dragon)
  • Nancy Wheeler (Stranger Things)
  • Obi-Wan Kenobi (Star Wars)
  • Oikawa Tooru (Haikyuu!!)
  • Peter Parker (Marvel)
  • Rey (Star Wars)
  • Steve Harrington (Stranger Things)
  • Wèi YÄ«ng | Wèi Wúxiàn (MDZS)
  • Will Graham (Hannibal) - top ranked character to appear only on the omega list


Characters who appeared only on the beta list included:

  • Alfred Pennyworth (DC)
  • Ashido Mina (BNHA)
  • Bruce Banner (Marvel)
  • Clint Barton (Marvel)
  • Han Jisung | Han (Stray Kids)
  • Hunk (Voltron)
  • Hwang Hyunjin (Stray Kids)
  • Kim Seungmin (Stray Kids)
  • Niall Horan (One Direction)
  • Sam Wilson (Marvel)
  • Sero Hanta (BNHA) - top ranked character to appear only on the beta list
  • Uraraka Ochako (BNHA)
  • Yang Jeongin | I.N (Stray Kids)


Were there any surprises for you in the data? Any character whose most popular omegaverse designation you disagree with?
shipperslist: nasa landsat image of a river looking like the letter S (Default)

[personal profile] shipperslist 2023-09-30 04:21 pm (UTC)(link)
Ahh, interesting stats! I'm very fond of omegaverse and it's one of the first tags I check out in a new fandom right after the canon divergence tag.
(I honestly would've thought Clint/Coulson would be there but nope.)
adore: (euphemism)

[personal profile] adore 2023-10-01 05:03 am (UTC)(link)
thank you for your service :D this is fascinating stuff. the bts graph didn't exactly surprise me, although jk's alpha bar is hella high. the percentage of omegaverse fic in BTS ficdom made me go 'whoa' and i'm also wondering whether jimin often being written as omega has any relation to jimin often being written as a sex worker. it's interesting to see patterns in the way they're headcannoned in ficdom.
adore: (i'm grateful for however much my eyes ca)

[personal profile] adore 2023-10-02 01:05 am (UTC)(link)
but I was surprised by how high the percentage of omegaverse fic was for BTS. I wonder why it's so popular there?

Although omegaverse sprouted in Supernatural fandom EXO fandom popularised omegaverse in non-western fandom after they released 'Wolf'. I suppose it made its way into other k-pop RPF from there, and BTS being the most popular k-pop fandom, one thing led to another?